The Top Ten Common Misconceptions about Thrift Stores, Debunked

thrifting-resplendent repurposing


Common misconceptions about thrift stores keep many people away. Here’s why they’re wrong.

By Mary Elizabeth Williams-Villano, LuxEco Editorial Assistant for the Resplendent Repurposing series

At this point, I’m hoping that I’ve piqued your interest about thrift store shopping — if not as a lifestyle, then at least as something to check out. Is it possible that you’ve passed many a Goodwill or Salvation Army thrift store in your travels but have never ventured inside? Could that be because you harbor some mistaken beliefs about these mysterious establishments? If so, it’s time to debunk these crippling common misconceptions about thrift stores so that you, too can enjoy this money-saving, eco-friendly treasure hunt. Along the way, I’ll give you some basic how-tos to guide your path. If you’ll be my Luke, I’ll be your Yoda. Learn much, we will.

Modern thrift stores run by well-known charities may not be glitzy – there are no shiny display cases, pianists or DJs, but they’re generally clean and well-organized. Some of the bric-a-brac may be a bit dusty, but I assure you there’s no need to don a Level Four Biohazard suit while shopping. If you’re worried, carry some hand sanitizer with you and spritz when you’re done.

Okay, I’m gonna level with you: There is an odor that I have dubbed “Thrift Store Funk” that may hit you when you first walk in the door. It’s kind of like a musty closet mixed with a topnote of old cologne, like the inside of Grandma’s purse. Some thrift stores have it worse than others — and many don’t have it at all.

It’s not that people donate dirty clothes to thrift stores. It’s just that in our sanitized, antibacterialized, Glade-infused culture, we’ve lost track of the fact that each of us has a natural scent. Even your cleanest clothes have a hint of Eau de You on them. (That’s why cats and dogs will curl up on our clothes, even when they’ve just been laundered.) Well, when you concentrate hundreds of items of used clothing together in one room, you concentrate all their former wearer’s scents together too. That’s what causes “Thrift Store Funk.”

If you’ve ever smelled expired food, a dirty diaper or New York City in the summer, you’ve smelled much, much worse. Unless you’re such a hothouse flower that the hint of any kind of off-aroma sends you reeling, you can take it. It’s very mild, and after a few minutes, you won’t even notice it.

Nonsense. Clothing in thrift stores is usually displayed by type, so all the women’s blouses will be in one section, the men’s pants in another and so forth. Since women’s tops are what they usually have the most of, they may be organized by color, so all the red blouses will be together, then the blue, etc. (Goodwill thrift stores do it this way.) Long-sleeved tops, short-sleeved tops, sweaters, dresses, skirts and pants will all have their own sections.

The sizes, however, will be mixed up. Don’t expect to find all the size tens on one rack. Petites, juniors, misses and plus sizes will all be commingled, so you’ll have to dig. (That’s part of the fun.) But this is not that big a deal. Most of us can tell immediately if something looks like it will fit us or not.

Well…sometimes that’s true. Thrift stores have to get the most out of their square footage, so they may not allot space for a dressing room. But many do, including every Goodwill thrift store I’ve ever been to.

My favorite thrift store chain in the greater L.A. area is run by the National Council of Jewish Women. None of the Council Thrift stores I’ve been to have dressing rooms, so I do the next best thing and slip items on over my clothes. The less bulky your shopping outfit, the easier this will be, so don’t wear your thickest cable-knit pullover with nothing on underneath. I try to wear filmy blouses or t-shirts that are easy to slip tops over. Skirts, too, can be slipped on over your head and down to your waist to see if they fit. Same for dresses. If it doesn’t fit, you should probably acquit yourself of it.

Pants are another matter. Here’s where it’s important to find out a thrift store’s return/exchange policy. I recently purchased some black leather pants at the Van Nuys Council Thrift Store. I was fairly certain they’d fit, but I couldn’t be absolutely sure. The clerk assured me that if they were too small or large, I could return them for store credit within three days. Since I shop there often, that suited me fine.

I’m not going to tell you that you won’t see some padded ‘80s shoulders and Brady Bunch neon polyester (that hasn’t already been swept up by a vintage dealer who’s actively seeking That ‘70s Stuff, that is). But the vast majority of a thrift store’s inventory consists of current styles in good or even new condition. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve bought items with the tags still on — and the tags weren’t from stores that went out of business twenty years ago.

Let’s not forget that some styles are classic. Some of the most fashionable women in the world wear vintage, including First Lady Michelle Obama. (By the way, want to hear my definition of a vintage clothing store? That’s a thrift store with a high markup.)

Untrue. Items of clothing that are stained, threadbare or moth-eaten are simply not put on sale — no one in America will buy them. Remember, they’re trying to make money. When thrift stores do get such items, they are sold in bulk to dealers who cut them up into industrial wiping rags or into fibers for paper products. Or, controversially, those same dealers resell them at a profit in the developing world, where our old clothes are unfortunately in demand. So where a few years ago you might have seen a woman in Ghana decked out in the traditional, colorful textiles, you might see see her today wearing a faded “Hard Rock Cafe Tijuana” t-shirt instead. Sad. But that’s a subject for another time.

There are many, many reasons why clothing ends up at thrift stores.  Some people discard clothes the way Kelsey Grammer discards wives. People gain weight, lose weight, change their style, lighten their load before moving, or simply tire of things. Some people follow the “if you haven’t worn it after a year, get rid of it” rule. There’s also estate clearance and getting rid of what didn’t sell at the yard sale. The National Council of Jewish Women thrift stores get a great many donations from upper-income women who, I suspect, don’t wish to be seen in an outfit more than a few times. It’s where I’ve found a great many of my best pieces. These clothes are beautiful, expensive and often classic in style.

Sure, thrift stores are a great source of cheap Halloween costumes (and wardrobe for school plays). In fact, that’s so well-known that some of the wackier stuff is often held in reserve and put out around that time of year on a special “Halloween” rack. But if you think that’s all thrift stores are good for, you’re very much mistaken.

Really? My bosses would have been shocked to hear that. Ninety percent of my wardrobe comes from thrift stores. Much of what I own could be, and has been, worn on the job or on job interviews in some of the most conservative office settings around.

A major part of a thrift store’s mission, besides making money for charity, is to provide serviceable clothing at low prices for low-income people so they can go to work. Most of the clothing will therefore fit that parameter.

So am I…now. In fact, it may surprise you to hear that shopping in thrift stores actually upped my game. I’ve found so many beautifully made, designer-label items that I’ve become kind of a clothing snob. Why would I go to a retail store to spend fifty, eighty, a hundred dollars or more on something that’s “just okay” when I already own a beautifully made designer piece that fits the same niche? I am now thoroughly spoiled. Even though I’m kinda broke right now, my closet’s full of leather, cashmere and silk — all thanks to my favorite thrift stores.

Now that I’ve shot down these common misconceptions, you’re ready to cross the threshold of your nearest thrift store. In you must go! Next time, I’ll share with you my Top Ten Thrift Store Finds.

See you at Council Thrift!

– Mary Elizabeth Williams-Villano

Subscribe / Share

Article by Mary Villano

Mary Elizabeth Williams-Villano doesn’t know how to describe herself and her spotty employment record. She’s been a radio DJ and talk show host, a magazine editor and a TV comedy writer. Her credits include the first three seasons of MAD TV (the funny years!) sixteen episodes of a cartoon called Aaah! Real Monsters!, the second season of Culture Clash’s sketch comedy show, and her first big break, the fifth, final (and unfortunately Wayans-free) season of In Living Color. She was also a co-writer of Denis Leary’s Merry Freakin’ Christmas special, in addition to dozens of other clay animation films she wrote or co-wrote with Spencer Green for Corky Quakenbush’s Space Bass Films. (You can catch her dark, perverse sense of humor on YouTube: Watch Davey and Son of Goliath or Raging Rudolph from her MAD TV days.) Mary can be found at the thrift store at least once a week, mumbling to herself and scoring amazing finds, not only in shoes and clothing but in stuff for the home -- finds that she’ll be sharing with LuxEcoLiving’s readers. Other, nerdier interests include scanning police and fire frequencies, amateur radio (call sign KI6OMJ) and trying to find spy numbers stations on shortwave. She also makes beaded jewelry. Mary shares a happy home in the charming little Dutch community of Van Nuys (that’s Lake Balboa to you!) with Mike, her hubby of thirteen years, four cats and numerous collections: Costume jewelry, purses, compacts, tiaras, floaty pens, vintage metal signs, tin-litho noisemakers, glassware, Kennedyana, bad taste/kitsch/politically incorrect items, vintage Christmas stuff and other odd bits of detritus too numerous to mention. Oh, and cat hair. Lots of it. Her goals in life include trying desperately to crank out novels and screenplays (like everyone else in L.A.!), not gaining weight and staying off A and E’s Hoarders. Read 8 articles by
9 Comments Post a Comment
  1. [...] View the original here: Resplendent Repurposing 101: Top Ten Thrift Store Myths, Busted … [...]

  2. Chris Martin says:

    My wife and I live the thrifter lifestyle, but most people wouldn’t know it. We’ve been doing it for quite awhile, and also have been working on our reality show concept called Continental Thrifters. We’ve spoken with Mike Wolfe of American Pickers, and he thought it was a cool concept. We have furnished our home with great furniture and great art, clothed our family in the lastest designer styles, and have made a very successful living from it as well. However, we want to show that being a thrifter is not about just getting by. We gross well over $100,000 a year working from home doing what we love to do. Our show idea is a travel and style based program that will take this concept further. We will highlight travel destinations around the country and the world, but also show the great thrift stores we find along the way. We meet some very interesting people, and give some background on that particular thrift store’s cause. This show will be both entertaining and informative. Our goal is to take away the stigma of being a thrift shopper. Keep an eye out for Continental Thrifters. We’ll be coming to your town soon.

  3. Rickie says:

    I usеԁ to be suggеѕted thiѕ web site bу way of my cousin.
    I’m now not positive whether or not this post is written via him as nobody else know such detailed about my difficulty. You are amazing! Thanks!

  4. [...] Some of you might be wondering whether second-hand clothing is acceptable in the professional world. Is it clean? Will it smell? Well, you certainly have to look around for quality. Spend a few extra dollars to get the item tailored and wash the clothes a few times with extra detergent, and I promise no one will know the difference. Plus, as Johnson mentioned, used clothing stores in upper-class neighborhoods often contain expensive garments donated by successful business people that you might not be able to afford new. Be selective, and do a thorough inspection of each garment before purchasing to ensure that it is in good condition. I completely agree with Johnson’s points about used clothing, and recommend it to anyone on a budget. A few others also agree with Johnson and I. To read more about used clothing and thrift store myths, read the articles here, here, and here. [...]

  5. Some sites can turn out to be scams to cheat you away
    from your money. The latest celebrity fashion brings dogs which are a high fashion commodity being traded in of recent.

    Wear some very short shorts or longer style shorts to help get started with the warmer weather.

    My web site long sleeve bodycon dress pattern

  6. She has a charm that is slightly reminiscent of the childhood favourite Rosie and Jim’s Ragdoll,
    with a modernized interior to suit the 21st century traveller.
    The options within the area range from Myall Lakes houseboats, cottages, apartments,
    cabins and guests houses, lodges and hotels among many others.
    A camera and photo album are another way for a family
    to record their boating trips.

    My blog – crock pot freezer meals on a budget

  7. Hi Dear Sir/Madam
    I would like to introduce my company Sanzaf Enterprises that manufacturer & exporters based in Sialkot/Pakistan.

    We produce all kinds of Hoodies,Shirts,Shorts,Socks,Gloves,caps/Hats,Customs uniforms with Embroidery,Printing and Sublimation.

    We also deal with all kinds of badges & Patches.

    We can offer to you our products at very special rates to start a good business relationship.

    Waiting for your earlier reply,

    Ahmad Saleem

    Sanzaf Enterprises
    Cell no: +92 303 6866365

Leave a Reply

Add video comment

Meet the LuxEco Team and Advocates

LuxEco Living Masthead

Nancy Chuda, Co-Founder of LuxEco Living and Healthy Child Healthy World
James Chuda, Co-Founder of LuxEco Living and Healthy Child Healthy World
Bethany Colson, Consulting Editor of LuxEco Living and Beauty Expert
Christopher David Kaufman, Marketing Director of LuxEco Living
Brooke Rewa, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Dow-Yung Kou, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Alanna Brown, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Jessica Borges, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Bradlee Gold, LuxEco Marketing Assistant
Derin Richardson, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Lauren O'Neill, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Hannah Canvasser, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Basil Vernon, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Michelle Dennis, LuxEco Marketing Assistant
Bernadette Bowman, LuxEco Advocate and Comedienne who writes the Life Goes Retrograde
F.R.E.E. Will, LuxEco Editorial Assistant and author of the In The Spice Cabinet series
Mary Villano, LuxEco Editorial Assistant and author of the Resplendent Repurposing series
Will Lana, Vice President of Trillium Asset Managment and LuxEco Advocate
Molly Rovero, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Leslie Harris, Interior Designer, Leslie Harris Interior Design and LuxEco Advocate
Kerin Van Hoosear, LuxEco Editorial Assistant and author of Kerin's Seasonal Cooking series
Kammie Daniels, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Lisa Adams, Designer and CEO of LA Closet Design and LuxEco Advocate
Sahar Ghaffari, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Joanna Bateman, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Dr. Harvey Karp, Pediatrician and Child Development Specialist and Creator of "The Happiest Baby on the Block” and “The Happiest Toddler on the Block” book and DVD series World and LuxEco Advocate
Florence "Flip" Ross, LuxEco Advocate
Nina Montee Karp, Executive Producer & Director The Path of Wellness & Healing and LuxEco Advocate
Emily Lynne Ion, LuxEco Advocate
Molly Cimikoski, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Lush Huxley, LuxEco Editorial Assistant
Rachel Lincoln Sarnoff, Executive Director/CEO of Healthy Child Healthy World and LuxEco Advocate
Zhenya Gershman, Artist and LuxEco Advocate
Anna Getty, Author and LuxEco Advocate
Christopher Gavigan, Board Member and Former Executive Director of Healthy Child Healthy World and LuxEco Advocate
Lewis Perkins, Founder of Women Are Saving The World Now and LuxEco Advocate
Francine LeFrak, Founder of Same Sky and LuxEco Advocate
Interested in contributing with our LuxEco Advocate program? We are looking for experts, researchers, academics, activists and everyday people who want to join our cause to make the world a safer, healthier place for all of and nature to flourish in, in harmony! Email the Manager Editor, Bethany Colson